Love Island’s Casey O’Gorman exposes bombshell Samie Elishi calling show ‘a joke’

Love Island All Stars winner Casey O’Gorman has shared a throwback video of Samie Elishi branding the ITV2 dating show ‘a joke’ after her third appearance

Casey O’Gorman has taken a dig at Love Island stunner Samie Elishi.

The 2025 All Stars champion posted an old video of Samie, in which she dismisses the ITV2 dating show as “a joke”.

Samie made a surprise return to the villa during Sunday’s (January 18) episode, joining new arrivals AJ Bunker and Konnor Ewudzi.

She first graced our screens on the ninth series of Love Island in 2023, where she starred alongside Casey, and later returned for the second series of All Stars last year. This was the series that saw Casey and Gabby Allen crowned winners.

In his recent Instagram post, Casey highlighted what he sees as Samie’s hypocrisy by reposting the clip of her criticising him, reports OK!.

Filmed from inside her car, Samie can be heard saying: “I’m sorry but I can’t help but laugh. Who has just seen the first look for Love Island?”.

**For the latest showbiz, TV, movie and streaming news, go to the new **Everything Gossip** website**

“Lord Farquaad is back, again. Haven’t we all had enough of Casey. The show’s a bit of a joke at this point.”

In response, Casey simply raised his drink and said: “Cheers, Samie.”

For those not in the know, Lord Farquaad is a character from the first Shrek film.

Casey’s Love Island journey includes appearances on series nine in 2023, both series of Love Island All Stars in 2024 and 2025, and Love Island Games in 2025.

Meanwhile, Scott van-der-Sluis made his comeback as the first bombshell of the current series, marking his fourth stint in the franchise after appearing on series 10, Love Island Games, Love Island USA and now All Stars.

Speaking about her third stint on the show, Samie stated: “I feel like my last time in the All Stars Villa, I didn’t get a fair shot and it’s such an amazing experience so if I can do it one more time, why not?”.

“I’m probably going to go in with the same attitude. I didn’t do anything that wasn’t true to myself last time. I will just be me again.

“I’ve grown up so much since Series 9 and my last time on All Stars you didn’t get to really see that.

“I want the audience to see how much I’ve grown and hopefully actually see me in a nice situation, coupled up with someone.”

Love Island: All Stars airs Sunday to Friday on ITV2 and ITVX at 9pm